Score: 9

"original work?"

submission: The Haunted Ballad

date: June 20, 2009

I think it would be best if you list either the song and author of the original song in the comments or put down it is an original work to avoid confusion. OK, The song was good, and I liked the piano. Keep creating.

Score: 9

"hey uhh, is thayou playing, very nice"

submission: The Way It Falls - Mjattie

date: May 31, 2009

the music is very smooth (like pianos usually are) ha, it was still very skillful. ww my 5 raised it .41. that's not bad at all. I likedit from begining to end really but its not really something you want t listen to repeatedly, no offence meant. keep makng music.

Score: 9

"i liked the beggining"

submission: Make Haste!

date: May 8, 2009

Although those instruments were in a loop, the addition of more instruments kept it from being boring. As for your comments, i wouldn't consider it subpar but it is lacking in some aspect of which i fail to recognize so i apologize. I don't know why it has such a low score, It could be succesful background music to a newgrounds game I think. Well, anyway keep at it.

Score: 9

"not really my opinion of good music"

submission: [DF] The Color of Sound

date: May 8, 2009

sorry, just not my style i guess. It had a catchy tune to it kinda though and it sounded like a great effort i do like how it fades out and back in at 2:10 or so just to change it up and those record scratching sounds helped it rom getting boring. I was barely able to give it a 5 but it deserved over a 4. Nice job, i don't know really what could have been improved, I guess it's just my opinion of music. Keep at it.

Score: 10

"i liked it"

submission: Lost In The Mirage

date: May 7, 2009

right when it started getting repetitve, the music changed, nice job. it kept a similar style the entire time without boring me. I especially liked it at about 2:25 when the strange piano sounds started happening but that tune was a bit too repetitive for me to be honest. I would shorten it to about 2:45 before I started the tuneout so unfortunately I think that part lasted a bit too long. but thanks for submitting music to newgrounds and i hope you continue to do so.

Score: 8

"hmm, it was good"

submission: Bananas (Final)

date: May 7, 2009

couldn't quite give it a 5, sorry, the music was pretty repetitive. but, i did enjoy it for about the first minute and i think a short submission with this music would be great. maybe you could cut off part of the song and put a different but similar style music after it, myou know so it's not a huge transition.

Score: 8

"Decent length and good song"

submission: Dandies (FRM)

date: November 11, 2008

hmmm... improvements, well i thought maybe it was too slow paced. I'm sorry I'm not really sure what I didn't like about it, it's a success when it can be applied to a flash submission.

Score: 10

"I really enjoyed the beggining"

submission: Breeze (demo)

date: November 11, 2008

It's a great song, nice job on it, I think it's ready to be used in a flash submission. Maybe it would go best in running flash, i don't know, sounds good, nice job.

Score: 9

"it's a good song"

submission: zelda through time

date: October 24, 2008

Nice changing the songs, well, i like the zelda games and I thought it was very awesome about 2 1/2 minutes to the end, my favorite part. Well, keep making music

Score: 8

"it is beethoven's song just to tell you"

submission: moonlight sonata tecno

date: October 23, 2008

but apparently everyone already told you so nevermind. It lost it's beat quite a bit and it just sounded like the instruments were gargled and with an extra beat to it. But again, i'm not the hugest fan of techno so I'm probably not the right person to tell you that but I am a fairly large classical music fan especcially when it comes down to Beethoven and a little bit of mozart. well It ruined it for me a bit, but oh well.